What’s the difference between a MIDI keyboard vs. a synthesizer?
A hardware synth can record MIDI, and a MIDI keyboard can control a synthesizer.
But their functions are entirely different.
Let’s compare the two, explain how they work, and help you decide which one to buy.
A synthesizer is a sound design tool that lets you create and manipulate sound. A MIDI keyboard lets you control other instruments, but it doesn’t produce sound. It sends MIDI signals to instruments, telling them how to play notes.
MIDI keyboard vs. Synthesizer: What’s the Difference?
A synthesizer is a sound design tool, while a MIDI keyboard is more of a programming tool.
Synths let you create sounds from audio waveforms and manipulate them using sound-shaping tools.
A MIDI keyboard is different from a synth because it doesn’t produce sound – it can tell instruments how to play notes.
But it’s not a standalone instrument like a synth or digital keyboard.
Hardware Synth vs. Software Synth:
A hardware Synth is a physical device. It has multiple sections for knobs that let you control different aspects of a sound.
It usually has a keyboard attached but gives you more control over sounds than a keyboard.
A Synth is a Sound Design Tool
Each synth is divided into multiple sections – each representing a different stage of the sound creation and design process.
A synth creates sound through oscillators that produce audio waveforms.
From there, this basic sound travel through a series of sound design tools – a filter, amplifier, envelope, arpeggiator, mixer, etc.; these tools are called parameters.
They let you shape an audio waveform to create a unique sound.
MIDI Keyboard vs Synthesizer: How MIDI is Different
MIDI controllers are primarily used to play virtual instruments in modern music production.
Unlike a synth, it always needs an external source to produce sound.
It can control a synth, but you can’t use it to create and shape sounds like you can with a synth.
What’s the Purpose of a MIDI Keyboard?
Music producers typically use MIDI keyboards for two reasons:
- Record basic chord progressions, baselines, and melodies instead of clicking in notes
- Simulate the feeling of playing a piano keyboard; record complex piano compositions
MIDI keyboards range from 25 to 88 keys.
25 – 49 key MIDI keyboards range from two to four octaves – making them sufficient for recording progressions, basslines, and melodies.
They’re also portable and ideal for limited studio space.
On the other hand, 61 – 88 key MIDI keyboards can simulate the feeling of playing a piano keyboard – especially with fully-weighted keys.
They’re ideal for fluent piano players who want to record patterns using two hands.
MIDI Keyboard vs Synthesizer: How One Each Works
How Does a MIDI Keyboard Work?
MIDI (musical instrument digital influence) is a language that allows MIDI controllers to communicate with other instruments.
Pressing keys on your MIDI keyboard sends MIDI data to your DAW via USB.
From there, your performance is visible in your piano roll when you record.
Virtual instruments understand MIDI messages and apply sounds to them.
How Does a Synthesizer Work?
Synthesize means to form by combining elements. A synthesizer does what its name suggests.
It produces sound through electrical signals. These electrical signals generate audio waveforms.
Each waveform sounds different based on how it vibrates and makes the air around it vibrate.
With a synthesizer, you can shape and manipulate these waveforms to create unique sounds.
Creating and Shaping Sounds with a Synth
Synthesizers are divided into sections.
There are oscillators that produce a waveform. And other sections where you can shape the waveform to manipulate the original sound; filter, envelope, modulation, amplifier, arpeggiator, mixer, etc.
Sections on a synth vary from model to model, but these are some of the most common ones:
Synthesizers create basic sounds using oscillators. Oscillators produce waveforms using electrical signals.
Each waveform sounds different because they have different shapes.
In other words, they vibrate through the air differently.
Common waveforms are sine waves, sawtooth waves, triangle waves, and square waves.
Some synths have multiple oscillators. This lets you layer sounds to create something unique.
In summary, the purpose of an oscillator is to produce a basic sound that you can manipulate.
Sound travels from oscillators to a filter section.
Filters in synths are like an EQ in your DAW.
They let you shape different frequency regions to produce a desired sound.
For example, you can remove unwanted low frequencies by applying a high pass filter (or letting high frequencies pass through). The same goes for cutting high frequencies with a low pass filter.
In general, filters let you shape and manipulate shape sound by emphasizing or minimizing certain regions of its waveform.
The envelope is where you can give the sound character.
It controls how the volume of a sound changes over time.
Sound travels in four stages when you press a key; this is called the ADSR envelope:
- Attack: how long does it take for a sound to reach its maximum level
- Decay: how long a sound stays at its maximum level
- Sustain: the volume level a sound remains at when you hold a note
- Release: how long it takes for sound to reach complete silence after a key is released
The envelope section of a synth allows you to control these aspects of a sound.
In general, with a synth, you can take a basic sound from a waveform and give it character.
Can I use a Synthesizer as a MIDI Controller?
Yes. You can use a synthesizer as a MIDI controller.
Modern synths will likely come with a USB port to directly connect to your computer.
If not, most will at least have a MIDI OUT port. This port allows synths to send MIDI signals to other devices.
If a synth only has MIDI ports, you can connect it to your computer to send MIDI signals in two ways:
- An audio interface with MIDI ports
- A MIDI to USB converter cable
Should I Buy a Synth or a MIDI Keyboard?
Between a MIDI keyboard and a synthesizer, you should buy a MIDI keyboard.
By synthesizer, we’re referring to a hardware synth.
They still have a place in music, especially for synth enthusiasts.
They also add a unique element to any live performance.
However, music production is becoming more digital these days.
Most DAWs come with software synths.
Also, some of the most popular third-party VSTs like Serum and Omnisphere are software synths.
If you’re a beginner, chances are you’ve been using a synth and haven’t realized it.
Brief History of MIDI Keyboard vs Synthesizer
Before the 1980s, all synths generated waveforms- sine, triangle, etc. – through analog circuit boards.
Once the 80s hit, digital synths came on the scene.
They create sound by processing digital signals as opposed to using analog circuits.
This difference compared to analog synth made them more portable and affordable.
Producers still use analog and digital hardware synths even though software synths are more widespread.
MIDI was also born in the 1980s following a period of large and expensive analog synths.
It was invented so instruments manufactured by different companies could communicate with each other – letting one control the other.
Today, MIDI is used in every DAW, allowing MIDI controllers to communicate with software instruments.
They both play an essential role in modern music production.
Synths are more likely to be used as VSTs, while MIDI keyboards are used in almost every studio
Check out this Youtube video by Jade Wii, “Synthesizer vs. MIDI Controller”.
Summary: MIDI Keyboard vs Synthesizer
- Programming tool – tells other instruments what notes to play and how to play them
- Needs and external sound source
- Can be used to control a synth
- Some come with knobs and faders to control parameters in your DAW
- Sound design tool – used to create and manipulate sound
- Hardware synth vs software synth – some of the most popular VSTs are software synths
- Can be used as a MIDI controller
- Come with knobs and faders to shape sound produced by waveforms